Image source, Getty Images
- author, James Delaney
- Role, BBC News
-
The First Minister faces a serious challenge at Holyrood after the collapse of the power-sharing agreement between the SNP government and the Scottish Greens.
He now wrote to all opposition parties but his appeal was immediately rejected by the Scottish Conservatives as “insulting and embarrassing”.
Youssef also said on Saturday that the unrest could lead to early elections in Scotland.
As he toured Fife, he again insisted he had no intention of resigning.
Asked if an election could be held at Holyrood, he told Sky News: “It cannot be ruled out.”
Scottish Parliament elections are usually held after a fixed period of five years, with the next election due to take place by May 2026.
The political turmoil began on Thursday when Youssef abruptly ended his power-sharing agreement with the Scottish Greens, known as the Boathouse Agreement.
The decision led to angry accusations from the Green Party, which later said they would support a motion of no confidence in the Prime Minister, put forward by the Scottish Conservatives.
Scottish Labor tabled a separate motion of no confidence on Friday, a motion that includes the entire Scottish Government and not just Mr Youssef.
This would force all ministers to resign if passed, while the Conservatives' proposal would not oblige Youssef to step down if adopted.
Letters were sent inviting the Scottish Conservatives, Scottish Labour, Green Party, Lib Dems and ALBA to hold talks at Bute House on Friday evening.
Youssef called for a “constructive contribution” while acknowledging that “strong feelings” remain in the run-up to next week’s elections.
“Every group within Parliament must contribute constructively, and I believe the people of Scotland want to see their political parties working together where and when they can, to build consensus for the common good,” he wrote.
“I recognize the strong feelings regarding the confidence debate that our Parliament is due to have next week.
“Despite this, I am writing to all Holyrood party groups to ask them to meet me next week, in separate meetings, to discuss their concerns and priorities, hopefully in a constructive spirit.”
Support price
The Scottish National Party has 63 members in the 129-seat Scottish Parliament, and must now govern as a minority government.
If the Greens vote with Labour, the Conservatives and the Scottish Liberal Democrats, Youssef will need the support of his former leadership rival Ash Reagan to survive no-confidence votes.
Regan, an outspoken critic of the Bute House Agreement and the Scottish Government's stance on transgender rights, defected from the SNP to the ALBA party last October.
At the time, Youssef described her departure from the SNP as “no great loss”.
Alba, founded by former First Minister Alex Salmond, said its national executive committee would meet over the weekend to discuss issues on which Regan would seek “action” ahead of negotiations.
She said the price for her support would be progress towards independence, protection of the rights of women and children, “competent governance” and work to prevent the closure of the Grangemouth refinery.
After receiving his letter from the First Minister, Scottish Conservative leader Douglas Ross described the letter as “insulting and embarrassing”.
He accused the Scottish National Party and the Green Party of “mismanaging” public services in Scotland during the agreement and called on Youssef to resign.
In a response issued on Saturday, Mr Ross wrote: “His own [Mr Yousaf’s] The late abandonment of the Boathouse agreement with the toxic Green Party – which he had supported just two days before he finally decided to withdraw it – does not undo the enormous damage it has done.
Humza Yousaf now talks about delivering “significant benefits to people, communities and businesses across the country”, and just wants to discuss “concerns and priorities” now that his job is on the line.
He added: “It is his abject failure to prioritize these issues that has led to a complete lack of confidence in his leadership through Parliament.”
Ross added: “He must now accept that his time in power is over and finally resign as First Minister.”
“If he does not do so before the Scottish Conservatives vote of no confidence in him next week, his future as First Minister depends on a vote that is currently so balanced that his credibility as leader will be completely destroyed, whatever the outcome.” “.
Kate Forbes urges loyalty
Kate Forbes, another former SNP leadership contender, urged SNP members to rally behind Youssef before the vote of confidence.
Ms Forbes, who came second in the competition, said “everyone who cares about Scotland” should support Mr Youssef.
Writing in the National“How we ended up here should be an embarrassment to every parliamentarian in every party,” she said.
She said abandoning the “overly ambitious” climate change targets should have led to “partners in government sitting down to agree on a practical plan to achieve these goals.”
“It is easy to be loyal to a party when times are good and the party is ahead in the polls,” she wrote in her column for the newspaper.
“But you discover what true leadership is – and what true loyalty looks like – when times are toughest and that is why I will be supporting the SNP and the First Minister through next week's battle and I urge everyone in our party and everyone who cares about Scotland to do the same.”
Former Business Secretary Ivan McKee said Youssef would likely be forced to resign if he lost the Conservative-led vote, although there was no legal obligation to do so.
He told BBC's Good Morning Scotland programme: “I don't think there's any doubt about that.
He added, “The vote of confidence, although not legally binding, will be a clear indication of Parliament's will.”
He added, “If you lose the vote of no confidence, it is clear that you do not have the confidence of Parliament.”
“But I think, as I said, the First Minister is using his political skills to negotiate to make sure he doesn't lose.”
Patrick Harvey, co-leader of the Scottish Greens, told the PA news agency on Friday that it was “pretty clear” Youssef had been unable to unite the Scottish Parliament.
He said: “He still has not provided any clarity on why he made such a dramatic shift and broke the promise on which he was elected as Prime Minister.”
“So it's very difficult to see how you can have a conversation that leads to a constructive outcome based on a lack of trust.”
In a radio interview on Friday, Green MSP Gillian MacKay cried as she described how “upset” she was by the termination of the agreement.
She told BBC Radio Scotland's Drivetime program that she had friends in government who were also “hurt” by the breakdown in relations.
“We had a good two-and-a-half years working together,” she said.
“It's really sad that it all had to be undone by one person.”
Youssef canceled his appearance in Glasgow on Friday, but later announced the minority government's first policy on a Dundee housing development.
He pledged an £80 million increase in affordable housing over two years, raising the affordable housing supply budget to £600 million in 2024/25.
He remained adamant that he “fully intends” to win votes of confidence.
He also said he would “absolutely” lead the SNP in the general election and the 2026 Holyrood elections.
“Infuriatingly humble analyst. Bacon maven. Proud food specialist. Certified reader. Avid writer. Zombie advocate. Incurable problem solver.”