Whenever something happens with Betelgeuse, speculation about it explodes as a supernova spawns. It would be great if you did. We’re far enough away not to suffer any consequences, so it’s fun to imagine the sky lighting up like that for months.
Now the red giant’s star has brightened by almost 50%, and this is again intensifying speculation.
Betelgeuse will explode as a supernova. On that, there is universal agreement. But the question of when is not certain. The star’s behavior is puzzling. How could a petty mortal know that?
– the case of Betelbot (betelbot) May 18, 2023
Betelgeuse isn’t just a red giant, it’s also a pulsating semicircular variable star. This means there is some periodicity in their brightness changes, although amplitudes can vary. It has a cycle of approximately 400 days during which its brightness changes. It also has a shorter cycle of 125 days, another cycle of 230 days, and a mega cycle of 2,200 days, all of which are determined by impulses. All of these cycles can make a star difficult to understand clearly.
Two years ago, Betelgeuse freaked out, and people wondered what that meant. It turns out that the star’s brightness has not, in fact, changed. Instead, the star ejected material from its surface that cooled into a dust cloud and blocked out the light. The episode is called “The Great Blackout”.
Now that it’s getting brighter, it’s once again attracting scientists’ attention. They want to know what developmental stage you are in and what all this activity means. New research shows it could explode as a supernova faster than anyone expected.
The new paper isThe developmental stage of Betelgeuse is inferred from the pulse periods. First author is Hideyuki Sayo of the Astronomical Institute, Graduate School of Science, Tohoku University, Japan. Monthly notifications of the Royal Astronomical Society accepted the paper for publication.
The more confusing parts of new research often make headlines. No sense argument against it. This is how humanity moves.
Yikes – serious scientific evidence that Betelgeuse could explode in “tens” of years.https://t.co/bgRqK9l97u
– Dr. Jan Eldridge (@astro_jje) June 2, 2023
We don’t pick Dr. Eldridge. She is not mistaken. It’s just that the paper says that’s just one possible outcome. It defines many others.
In their paper, the authors say that Betelgeuse could be the next supernova of the Milky Way, regardless of which their findings may be correct. “We conclude that Betelgeuse is in the final stage of primary carbon burning, and is a good candidate for the next galactic supernova,” they wrote.
As a red giant, it left Betelgeuse main sequence. throughout a long time 8 to 8.5 million years ago history, they have consumed massive amounts of hydrogen by fusing it into helium and releasing the mass lost from this fusion as energy. (Thanks to Einstein.) This means that it no longer fuses hydrogen into helium like the sun does. When stars like Betelgeuse lose mass, their gravity can no longer contain their outward pressure, and they expand to form a more massive envelope. So even though they lose mass, they grow in size.
After stars like Betelgeuse leave the main sequence and no longer fuse hydrogen into helium in their cores, things change dramatically. during the helium fusion The next stage, carbon builds up in its core. Then they start the primary carbon burning period which produces other elements. The authors of the new paper say that Betelgeuse is in the late stages of that period.
But for how long? How long do you stay? There is no exact answer to that yet.
“Despite, and in part because of, the relatively small distance from Earth, it has been difficult to obtain strict constraints on distance, luminosity, radius, current masses and zero-age main sequence (ZAMS), information about the internal rotational state and associated mixing thus on the evolutionary status of Betelgeuse and when it might explode,” write the authors New review from Betelgeuse. ZAMS is particularly important for understanding the evolutionary stage of specific stars. It is fundamental, though not the only one responsible.
But the study offers some strong possibilities.
The work is a mixture of notes and models, each of which fits the notes in different ways. It’s a tricky business, which is why headlines or tweets claiming it could explode in decades are a bit misleading. Small differences rarely attract attention.
The primary carbon burning period consists of several stages. The difficulty in determining when Betelgeuse will go supernova partly comes from determining which phases it goes through. His distance from us is also a matter of debate. Betelgeuse’s review states that “although it lies at a distance of only 200 parsecs from Earth, and can therefore be resolved spatially with appropriate instrumentation, the uncertainty that departs from it remains a critical barrier to deeper understanding”.
What caught everyone’s attention were these two sentences from the research: “According to this figure, the core will collapse within a few dozen years after carbon is exhausted. This indicates Betelgeuse to be a very good candidate for the next galactic supernova, which occurs very close to us.”
This is the number they are talking about.
But what didn’t attract much attention was the next part of the paper.
“In fact, it is not possible to accurately determine the evolutionary stage, because surface conditions hardly change at the late stage near carbon depletion and beyond,” the researchers write. Astronomers can only see the surface, but it’s what’s going on deep within the star that tells the tale.
The paper’s authors really say that, according to observations, data, and modeling, Betelgeuse could explode sooner than thought. But – and this is crucial – they don’t know at what stage the star’s primary carbon is burning. Carbon combustion can continue for a long time, according to some models that fit the data.
Or maybe hundreds of years, if their model D applies from Table 2 and if I’m reading the paper correctly. But yeah, let’s hope it’s dozens!
– Jonathan McDowell (@planet4589) June 2, 2023
But not everyone agrees that Betelgeuse is in the primary carbon-burning phase. The authors of the Betelgeuse review say that the star is still in the helium phase. Since the primary helium burn is much longer than the later combustion stages, Betelgeuse is likely to be at the helium burning core. The pulsation period likely constrains the radius, distance, and evolutionary state of the primary helium burner,” they write, while acknowledging that there are “arguments to the contrary.”
Another way the researchers have tried to determine the timing of the supernova’s explosion is to match its periodic pulsations to similar models. This is what Jonathan McDowell is referring to in the tweet above.
When it finally explodes—and no one disagrees with its final explosion as a supernova—it’s not likely to produce a deadly gamma-ray burst as some supernovae do. And while the material will come out and produce powerful X-rays and ultraviolet rays, we’re very far from being affected. Instead, it will be a light show visible to all of humanity, and that will change the constellation of Orion forever. Scientists say it will most likely leave a neutron star, perhaps a pulsar that will be visible for millions of years. The entire event, from start to finish, will be an unprecedented opportunity to study the evolution of stars, supernovae, and stellar remnants. Scientists will be able to work backwards from exploding into all the research that has been done and all the observations and data and identifying where they were right and where they were wrong. Old Betelgeuse will teach them a lot.
The shock wave from the supernova will arrive in 100,000 years and will be easily deflected by our sun’s heliomagnetosphere. The biggest impact on Earth will be an increase in cosmic rays hitting the upper atmosphere.
Most of us will look on at this cataclysmic eruption and sit in awe of the force of nature, we hope, while others will turn to outlandish conspiracy theories or quasi-religious, pseudoscientific, cult-like reverence.
If humanity still existed when the blessed event occurred.
“Infuriatingly humble alcohol fanatic. Unapologetic beer practitioner. Analyst.”