Microsoft's latest operating system, Windows XP has been on the market now long enough for most people to decide whether or not they want to install and use it on their systems. It's easily the smoothest, prettiest and most stable OS yet from Microsoft. But is it fast? Everyone is saying it is....but we are going to show you a quick comparison today to let you know just how much faster, if any, than XP is over Windows 98 Second Edition, from a Gamer/Overclocker's perspective. Not a long article indeed, yet a view of several different benchmarking programs that will compare the two operating systems head to head.
Microsoft Windows 98SE vs WinXP

Microsoft's latest operating system, Windows XP has been on the market now long enough for most people to decide whether or not they want to install and use it on their systems. It's easily the smoothest, prettiest and most stable OS yet from Microsoft. But is it fast? Everyone is saying it is....but we are going to show you a quick comparison today to let you know just how much faster, if any, than XP is over Windows 98 Second Edition, from a Gamer/Overclocker's perspective. Not a long article indeed, yet a view of several different benchmarking programs that will compare the two operating systems head to head.
Test System:
Windows 98 SE and Windows XP Professional, running on the following system:
AMD 1.4GHz Tbird CPU @1500MHz
MSI K7T266 Pro2-RU Motherboard
256megs of Kingmax PC2400 DDR
Maxtor 40G 7200rpm HD
Visiontek GF3 Video Card

Both versions of Windows freshly installed on Identically matched hard drives. nVidia Detonator 21.83 Drivers used for both systems, with default settings (no tweaks). Via 4.35 4in1's used for both. Both 98SE and XP were fully updated using Microsoft's Windows Update function. 98SE was installed using FAT32 and XP was installed using naitive NTFS.
Benchmarks: Lets get right down to it and start of with some SiSoft Sandra Benchmarks. Theoretically, CPU, Multi-Media and Memory benchmarks should be the same. Lets take a look.



Just as we suspected. Each OS running @1500MHz is pretty much neck and neck. Neither score negligibly above the other in both marks. Lets see what Multi-Media scores show us.


Here we see Win98 winning in the raw Integer score, and XP wins Floating Point, which is to be expected as XP has more enhancements for newer chip technology such as MMX, 3DNow...etc. Memory scores below.


Windows XP is pulling slightly ahead in both FPU and INT MMX scores, but not by much. Certainly not enough to get excited about, and as we suspected before, Win98 and XP are competitive given identical hardware. One thing I would like to mention though is that XP appears to handle memory leaks MUCH better than Win98. Upon consecutive runs of the SiSoft Memory Test, Win98SE scores drop lower and lower and lower with each additional test. While XP scores stay relatively the same no matter how many times they are run. In interesting note to say the least.
Lets move on to 3DMark2000 and 2001 to see what type of differences we'll see with gaming and video benchmarks.

Here we are seeing Windows 98SE as the clear winner. Even though nVidia drivers have been optimized for XP, 98 takes the crown in this category for both iterations of 3DMark. Lets see some Quake3 action next.



Windows 98SE wins this competition as well. Showing more FPS in resolutions below 1600x1200. Our video card is the bottle neck at that resolution so CPU and/or OS will not affect that score, but again, Win98SE is more efficient in the 640x480 and 1024x768 resolutions.
The next benchmark we have is AMD's very own N-Bench. This is the first time we are using this benchmarking program at OCA and will most likely incorporate it into our future reviews for benchmarking purposes. Lets see how the numbers stack up.


Keeping with the trend, it looks as if Win98SE dominates slightly in N-Bench scores. Showing a higher total score as well as higher average frames per second. Ok, lets finish this off with Dronezmark.


Quite a different benchmark than most. DronezMark shows you the minimum, maximum, and average frames per second which is really quite informative, as opposed to a simple score. Dronez utilizes nVidia's nFiniteFX engine and is also highly tuned for Intel's P4 processor. With this, we see Windows XP's performance above that of 98SE in Maximum fps as well as average. 98 ends up higher in minimum fps.
Conclusion: It looks as if we'll have to give the SPeeD crown to Windows 98SE. While XP is Microsoft's greatest effort in the OS arena to date, 98 comes out on top for raw performance. XP will give you bells and whistles, a smooth interface, and stability, but if your looking for every bit of performance you can squeeze out of your system, chances are good you'll want to keep a separate partition on your hard drive with 98SE installed.
One thing we need to keep in mind as well. Neither operating systems were tweaked in this review. There are several XP tweaks out there that will surely boost performance and bring any of these individual benchmarks up quite a bit. So it all boils down to what is convenient for you, and does an extra 5 frames per second in your favorite game matter when it comes down to the wire. Be sure to checkout our review of Windows XP if you are thinking about upgrading and want a quick glance at what you can expect with XP.
| DISCLAIMER: The content provided in this article is not warranted or guaranteed by Developer Shed, Inc. The content provided is intended for entertainment and/or educational purposes in order to introduce to the reader key ideas, concepts, and/or product reviews. As such it is incumbent upon the reader to employ real-world tactics for security and implementation of best practices. We are not liable for any negative consequences that may result from implementing any information covered in our articles or tutorials. If this is a hardware review, it is not recommended to open and/or modify your hardware. |
More Software Articles
More By SPeeD
developerWorks - FREE Tools! |
Informix Dynamic Server (IDS) Express Edition offers outstanding online transaction processing (OLTP) database performance, while helping to simplify and automate many of the tasks associated with deploying databases for small business applications. IDS 11 further extends the ease of management and applications integration with the Admin API and Scheduler, high availability with Continuous Log Restore for backup server recovery in case of a primary server failure, and column level encryption to protect personal and company private data. FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
In this webcast, IBM Rational will discuss the importance of Web application security and will share techniques and best practices to introduce application security testing into current QA processes including: understanding common security vulnerabilities and techniques to integrate security testing with defect tracking and remediation systems in an effort to safeguard sensitive online information. FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
As organizations integrate software into every aspect of business, they are constantly pressured to deliver faster, better, and cheaper results. Unfortunately, a “dis-integrated” software delivery approach reduces returns while increasing costs. This IBM Rational White Paper shows how Integrated Requirements Management aligns organizations around maximizing value and keeping pace with change. FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
The discipline of assembling and delivering software is maturing beyond standard developer-centric compile/test software builds. The end-to-end software development lifecycle is emerging as the new focus moves “Beyond the Build.” Join this on demand webcast to learn about methods for streamlining software delivery and key capabilities of the IBM Rational Build Forge framework for automating build and release management in environments of any size. FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
This paper is about the critical role that a discipline called integrated requirements management can play in helping to ensure that your business goals and IT investments are continuously aligned—whether you are sourcing, integrating, building or maintaining software. It also looks at ways that automated IBM Rational® products can work together to help you use requirements in the very best way. FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
Download a free trial version of IBM Rational Software Analyzer Developer Edition V7.0 to identify bug defects earlier in the software development cycle. Rational Software Analyzer is an extensible software development solution that reduces the expense of bug-fixes by enabling static analysis code reviews and bug identification very early in the development cycle. FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
Asset Reuse is a key strategy for companies looking to create innovative solutions to solve complex software development problems. Searching for, identifying, updating, using and deploying software assets can be a difficult challenge. Listen to this webcast, to learn about strategies and tools that you can leverage for a successful project, including Rational Asset Manager, Rational Software Architect and WebSphere Service Registry and Repository. FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
User communities play an important role in communication and collaboration around products, solutions and other areas of special interest to members. Successful communities are able to provide the right mix of content and services to deliver a value proposition that resonates with each audience. Join Tom Inman, VP of Marketing for Information and Platform Solutions as he introduces the new LeverageINFORMATION community. During this webcast, learn about the value provided by the community and how customers and partners derive value from the community in addressing their own technical and business challenges. FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
WebSphere Process Server delivers a unique integration framework that simplifies existing IT resources. Often, as IT assets grow to support business demand, so too does their complexity and manageability. In this webcast, we’ll discuss how WebSphere Process Server helps deliver an SOA infrastructure that provides a common model to orchestrate, mediate, connect, map, and execute the underlying IT functions. Discover how WebSphere Process Server simplifies integration of business processes by leveraging existing IT assets as reusable services without the complexities of traditional integration methodologies. FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
Learn to enable users to both rate existing animations and to combine existing animations into new snippets. This is the third in a series of three tutorials that chronicle the building of a site that enables collaborative discussion and animation building using Domino and OpenLaszlo. FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
All FREE IBM® developerWorks Tools! |