Now that AMD’s reign of overclocking is coming to an end, many enthusiast's have been migrating over to the Pentium IV Northwood's. Heck, even the new Willamette Celerons are overclocking pretty decently. Yes overclocking the processor is fun, but it sure gets dangerous when you don’t have proper cooling. Giving the extra juice of voltage and squeezing out every little bit of power strains the processor and creates tons of heat. Even though the socket 478 processors are supposed to run cooler than AMD's, they still generate quite a bit of heat. When it comes to having proper cooling for my processors, I use nothing but the best. I recommend nothing but the best, even though the best may be a bit pricier than what most people can afford. In the end, the extra bucks that you spend on the piece of metal can help you in the long run.
Product: Swiftech MCX4000 vs. Alpha PAL8942
Price: $47 and $32 respectively
Availability: Now
Written by: poiuy223
Reviewed: August, 2002
Edited by: Mack (SPeeD) Littleton
INTRODUCTION: Now that AMD’s reign of overclocking is coming to an end, many enthusiast's have been migrating over to the Pentium IV Northwood's. Heck, even the new Willamette Celerons are overclocking pretty decently. Yes overclocking the processor is fun, but it sure gets dangerous when you don’t have proper cooling. Giving the extra juice of voltage and squeezing out every little bit of power strains the processor and creates tons of heat. Even though the socket 478 processors are supposed to run cooler than AMD's, they still generate quite a bit of heat. When it comes to having proper cooling for my processors, I use nothing but the best. I recommend nothing but the best, even though the best may be a bit pricier than what most people can afford. In the end, the extra bucks that you spend on the piece of metal can help you in the long run.
Today is a battle between the two best heatsink manufacturers I’ve ever worked with. Both companies use their ingenious design of pins instead of the normal fin type construction with their heatsinks.
ALPHA PAL8942: The Alpha line of products is very impressive and is in my opinion the best for your money. Their two previous heatsinks of PAL6035 and the PAL8045 were superb and performed to reach and even exceed my expectations and standards. I had no doubt that the PAL8942 would not disappoint.
The PAL8942 comes packaged in a white cardboard box with the Alpha logo on the cover. Inside the package are two bags of screws—one for the mounting screws and nuts and one with the fan screws. There are two sets of fan screws—one for the 80x10mm fans and one for the standard 80x25mm fans. Alpha includes a sheet on how to install the heatsink and gives step by step instructions with lots of pictures. Alpha also includes an extra screw and spring for those of you who are clumsy.
The heatsink itself is massive. The PAL8942 has a copper bottom with aluminum pins. The copper bottom is fairly shiny and is smooth and makes excellent contact with your cpu. Each pin is hexagonal and not cylindrical. This design creates more surface area. The pins are spaced evenly with good amount of space for air to work with. If the pins are too close to each other, it would force the air into a tight squeeze and thus increase the noise level. Alpha designs their heatsinks with a shroud in such a way that the fan sucks air off of the heatsink and upward instead of blowing down onto the heatsink itself. Here, the shroud has the white protective wrap removed, revealing the shiny metal. Remember, the fan needs to suck air out instead of blowing down on the heatsink. There is a difference in performance if installed incorrectly.
SWIFTECH MCX4000: Swiftech is a well known name in the overclocking community. Their budget line of the MC series works really well and can be recommended over many expensive heatsinks. At first, the only solution to the socket 478 or the socket 423 would be to use the MCX462 and use a bracket. After the socket 478 grew in popularity, Swiftech came up with a new solution—the MCX4000. It is made exclusively for the socket 478. It is bigger and has more pins than the MCX462. When I received it, I opened the box and my jaws dropped (well, not literally). The package came in a brown cardboard box with a Swiftech label on the front.
There are 4 pieces of Styrofoam surrounding the heatsink so that it doesn’t move around during its shipping process. Included in the box are two bags for the mounting system. What surprised me was that Swiftech included a small pack of Arctic Silver Alumina. Although the alumina may not be the top performing grease, it is definitely better than the standard white silicone grease. Like Alpha, Swiftech also included a sheet of instructions for installing the heatsink. Although Swiftech sells the MCX4000 with the Y.S. Tech TMD fan (which will be covered in our next look at the full Swiftech MCX4000 package), for testing purposes, I removed the fan to use the Sunon 80mm fan. Removing the TMD fan showed the 4 rubber spacers. Swiftech included these to give the fan a bit of height above the heatsink to provide better airflow. These rubber spacers also absorb the fan vibration and lessen the noise level. The bottom of the heatsink is a thick copper plate. The square piece in the middle, which is the contact, is not as shiny as the surrounding. Swiftech also uses aluminum pins, but unlike Alpha, they design their pins with ridges, or Helocoid pins which create more surface area. According to Swiftech, the ridges on the pins also help airflow. Here is some official info below.
70mm and 80mm fan compatibility : allows users to install any 70 or 80mm fan, providing optimum choice in noise vs. performance . For a good balance of performance versus noise, we recommend using the factory stock 70mm TMD® fan. Extreme overclockers will be also be able to use ultra high-flow 80mm fans.
TESTING: To test the real potential of the heatsinks, I’ve included no case fans in the test bed. I used a temperature probe on the processor and the Northbridge passive heatsink (just because I had two). A fresh thin layer of Arctic Silver II was applied on the processor for each heatsink. The case sits tightly under my desk during the testing procedures. The fan I used was the Sunon 80mm x 25mm fan. It is a very common fan used for CPU HSF's and blowholes alike. It is also relatively quiet and provides a steady stream of 36CFM. The ambient room temperature was kept at a constant 73F. Air conditioning was kept on during the entire testing process.
Test System:
Intel Celeron 1700@1870 (17x110)
MSI MS-6528 LE
256mb Corsair PC150
512mb Corsair PC133
Seagate 20gb Barracuda III
Morpheus GeForce3
3com 905cx NIC
Pioneer 10x DVD
Antec Mini Tower KS382
Test Fans:
Sunon 80mm 36 CFM @ 2800 RPM, 32.5 dBA
Test Burn-Ins:
SETI (15 minutes)
Sisoft CPU Burn-In (10 loops)
3dmark2k1se patched (5 loops)
RESULTS:
SIDE NOTES:
Both heatsinks are very heavy but easy to install. In my upcoming motherboard review, I used the Alpha PAL8942 as my heatsink. The heatsink was so heavy that it would bend my Abit BD7 motherboard. Extra large motherboards should definitely use all mounting holes available. It would be disastrous to see the heatsink fall off and crush all your expensive cards below. With this said, the MCX4000 is also a concern.
CONCERNS:
Alpha: The spring that comes with the PAL8942 is very tight and squeaks when the screw is turned. It is not as easy to remove as the Swiftech.
Swiftech: The included screws for the fan are not as long to fit the Sunon 80mm fan I used in this test. I had to do some modifications in order for the fan to fit.
CONCLUSION: So there you have it. The battle between the two best heatsink manufacturers has ended and the winner crowned. Swiftech still lives up to its name and proves itself to be the champion. True that the Swiftech is the top performer, but it doesn’t leave the Alpha out of the picture. Most people don’t have the kind of money to spend on the best heatsink. Most people would consider spending $30-$40 a little too expensive. The Alpha in my opinion would the best choice for those people. The price difference between the two bare heatsinks is roughly $15. For those who definitely need the best of the best, Swiftech would be the choice. Otherwise, I would recommend the Alpha.
PROS/CONS:
Alpha
PROS: Easy to install, has lots of pins, comes well packaged, performs well, has extra screw and spring, price, nice black finish
CONS: Springs a bit stiff, too heavy and bends motherboard if motherboard not installed correctly
RATING: 8 out of 10
Swiftech
PROS: Easy to install, has lots of pins, comes well packaged, performs EXTREMELY well, comes with a small pack of Arctic Alumina, shiny copper finish
CONS: Fan screws a bit too short, no extra screw or spring for “accidents”, also bends motherboards that are not installed correctly
RATING: 9 out of 10
And the winner is!? The Swiftech MCX4000. We liked this coolers revolutionary design, excellent heat dissipation and all around quality construction, we felt it easily deserved the coveted "OCA Approved" award.
We'd like to thank Sidewindercomputers for providing the Swiftech MCX4000. And thanks to Alpha Company Ltd. for providing the excellent Alpha PAL8942 which is also stocked @Sidewindercomputers. They gave us the opportunity to match these two monsters of cooling head to head. Not only does Sidewinder have a great cooling selection, they have great prices and awesome customer service too. Trust me, we were their #1 customers before we made them our sponsors!
Thanks for stopping by and checking out the review. Feel free to head into the forums for discussion, or stop by the Front Page and check out the more GooSH!™ here at OCA..
| DISCLAIMER: The content provided in this article is not warranted or guaranteed by Developer Shed, Inc. The content provided is intended for entertainment and/or educational purposes in order to introduce to the reader key ideas, concepts, and/or product reviews. As such it is incumbent upon the reader to employ real-world tactics for security and implementation of best practices. We are not liable for any negative consequences that may result from implementing any information covered in our articles or tutorials. If this is a hardware review, it is not recommended to open and/or modify your hardware. |
More PC Cooling Articles
More By Poiuy223
| Recommended by Dev Hardware |
|---|
|
 developerWorks - FREE Tools!
|
Join us for this on demand webcast to learn about developing complex systems more quickly and efficiently. We'll cover market drivers for developing, governing and reusing systems software assets and how you can develop system software assets with Rational Asset Manager.
FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
Discover how IBM Rational AppScan Standard Edition can help you detext vulnerabilities in your web applications in the Web Application Security eKit. IBM Rational AppScan is a leading suite of automated web application security solutions that scan and test for common Web application vulnerabilities. The new Web Application Security eKit provides you with valuable resources, including white papers, demos, and additional information on the benefits of testing your Web applications.
FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
Manage, govern, and share services across your organization by using WebSphere Service Registry and Repository. Follow the hands-on exercises to learn how to navigate the Web interface to publish, find, reuse, and update services.
FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
Learn from the best! Find out how developers use Rational ClearCase to be more flexible, innovative and deliver higher quality code in the Rational ClearCase Power Users eKit. This complimentary eKit provides a collection of materials, like articles, whitepapers, and demos that can help you become a power user of Rational ClearCase.
FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
This Fall, IBM Rational talks to you directly through a special teleconference series giving you access to the best minds in IBM Rational - product experts and market thought leaders who will answer your questions during these pre-scheduled telephone conference calls. Register today!
FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
Rational Build Forge Express Edition is an automation framework that packages the latest enterprise-grade technologies into a reliable, flexible and robust configuration designed and priced specifically for small to midsize businesses. The new Rational Build Forge Express eKit provides you with valuable resources – including a case study, podcast, demo, and articles – to help you increase staff productivity, compress development cycles and deliver better software, fast.
FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
Join this Rational Talks to You teleconference on December 6 at 1:00 pm ET to participate in an agile application development discussion and get your questions answered on using IBM Rational Method Composer in a distributed environment.Get your questions answered!
FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
Regression testing -- in which code is thoroughly tested to ensure that changes have not produced unexpected results -- is an important part of any development process. But many testing environments neglect the terminal-based applications that still form the backbone of many industries. In this tutorial, you'll learn how the Rational Functional Tester Extension for Terminal-Based Applications works with other Rational Functional Tester to help test terminal-based applications quickly and easily.
FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
Get a free trial download of the latest version of IBM Rational Tester for SOA Quality V7.0.1, a functional and regression testing tool that enables the creation, comprehension, modification and execution of testing GUI-less Web services.
FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
WebSphere Process Server delivers a unique integration framework that simplifies existing IT resources. Often, as IT assets grow to support business demand, so too does their complexity and manageability. In this webcast, we’ll discuss how WebSphere Process Server helps deliver an SOA infrastructure that provides a common model to orchestrate, mediate, connect, map, and execute the underlying IT functions. Discover how WebSphere Process Server simplifies integration of business processes by leveraging existing IT assets as reusable services without the complexities of traditional integration methodologies.
FREE! Go There Now!
|
|
|
|
All FREE IBM® developerWorks Tools!
|
